Monday, November 8, 2010

Do we really need more education reform?

One thing that you hear a lot about during the election season, and through out the rest of the year, as well, is education reform.  There is no doubt that our young people are the future of our great nation, so education should be one of our greatest concerns.

So why have decades of education reform resulted in failure?  I submit to you that public education as it stands today cannot be reformed, because
it is working exactly the way it was designed to. 

Many people live under the mistaken conclusion that public education was set into place to meet the needs of children living in poverty, who, it is supposed, received no education because their parents could not afford to send them away to what would have then been the equivalent of expensive private schools today.

However, the sad fact is that nothing could be further from the truth.  The TRUTH is, that in early America, the literacy rate hovered near 100%.  The TRUTH is, there were publicly funded schools.  They were just not FEDERALLY funded; they were not even STATE funded, they were funded locally by the families who were using them.  The TRUTH is, that the federal compulsory school system was never intended to free children from the bondage of ignorance, because there was no bondage of ignorance.

With the rise of the industrial revolution, it became evident that there was one large obstacle to corporate domination.  Free enterprise.

As long as we were a nation of freely educated, creative, ambition, frugal people, the large corporations would always be at risk of collapse.  That is the hard law of competition.  Every creative and driven young man was a threat to the towering empires of wealthy families.  Every smart and innovative child could become the next American millionaire.  These companies needed two things to thrive:  Consumers and workers.  The public school system was a way to produce both, while at the same time limiting creative thought and uniqueness.

Ringing bells.
Age segregation.
Extension of childhood long beyond historical ages.
Separation from parents.
Younger and younger students.
Lowering standards.
Removal of proven methods. (Phonics, Arithmetic, Latin...)
Creative thought discouraged.
Adding meals to the school day.
Rewarding conformity and disciplining independent thinkers.
Classical schooling completely removed.

All of these things point directly to an underlying system.  And it is working exactly like it is supposed to.  

I just want to add that I have the greatest respect and admiration for our public school teachers.  Most of them are doing the best they can in a system that has undermined them from the very beginning.  Most teachers are trying, really trying, to teach their students and most of them succeed against overwhelming odds.  But the cost to our countries greatest asset, creative thought, is devastating.  The system is failing teachers as much as it is children.  

What do you think about our failing education system?  Can it be reformed?


  1. No, I agree, it cannot be reformed or fixed while still built on the same foundation. It is sad, as you see fewer and fewer competent graduates of our public institutions. A 14 year old pioneer schoolhouse graduate could read, write, spell, and figure circles around most of our public school graduates, who spent several more years in school and came out with nothing to show for it. Sigh. Yet another reason we are blessed to be able to homeschool!

  2. So TRUE! Public schools have nothing on homeschoolers, nothing! Its sad to see such a great thing be so overlooked as the homeschooling world. There used to be 1 room school houses that all the kids went to that lived in the area, now like you said they are all seperated and the ages to start school is startling to me, preschool at age 3! Kids should be learning to have fun and some of the subjects PS teaches such as sex education should be over and done with, to me that is something kids learn from a parent not a health teacher in 6th grade! They are not going to be able to fix the PS system unless they change their values and beliefs and go back to how it used to be before the government took control of our lives---I agree with Tristan its GREAT to be a homeschooler!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...